{"proof":{"url":"https://trustgrowth.ai/proofs/atlasofthinkers-com","short_url":"https://trustgrowth.ai/p/atlasofthinkers-com","api_url":"https://trustgrowth.ai/api/v1/proofs/atlasofthinkers-com"},"site":{"slug":"atlasofthinkers-com","name":"Atlas of Thinkers","domain":"atlasofthinkers.com","language":"en","story_mode":false,"verified_since":"2026-09-13T10:56:14Z","published_on":"2026-06-15","updated_on":"2026-09-13"},"narrative":{"title":"atlasofthinkers.com — Verified Growth","description":"atlasofthinkers.com GSC-verified growth: 0% click change, 0 ranking keywords. E-E-A-T scores and SEO audit signals via TrustGrowth.","author_name":"Seyfi Cem Baskın"},"summary":{"overall_score":27,"score_delta":null,"click_growth_pct":0,"keyword_count":0,"keywords_in_top_10":0,"published_content_count":0,"geo_score":38,"geo_eligible":false,"total_clicks":1,"total_impressions":1037,"latest_clicks":1,"latest_impressions":539,"latest_position":"39.9","ctr_pct":0.1,"avg_position":39.9},"scores":{"latest":{"score_date":"2026-09-13","overall_score":27,"technical_score":59,"content_score":44,"performance_score":51,"growth_score":null,"eeat_score":81,"authority_score":2,"visibility_score":23,"geo_score":38,"eeat_experience":80.0,"eeat_expertise":100.0,"eeat_authoritativeness":null,"eeat_trustworthiness":61.9,"signal_evidence_score_date":"2026-09-13"},"panels":{"technical":59,"content":44,"performance":51,"growth":null,"eeat":81,"authority":2,"visibility":23,"geo":38},"eeat_breakdown":{"experience":80,"expertise":100,"authoritativeness":null,"trustworthiness":62},"trajectory":[],"evidence":{"score_state":"provisional","provisional":true,"uncertainty":{"lower":25,"upper":29},"present":5,"total":9,"confidence_weighted_coverage":67.55},"pillar_states":{"geo_v5":{"state":"maturing","confidence":0.9,"missing_reason":"readiness_never_run"},"eeat_v3":{"state":"measured","confidence":1.0,"missing_reason":null},"growth_v4":{"state":"stale","confidence":0.0,"missing_reason":"growth_observations_stale"},"content_v5":{"state":"maturing","confidence":0.85,"missing_reason":"content_evidence_partial"},"authority_v4":{"state":"measured","confidence":1.0,"missing_reason":null},"technical_v5":{"state":"measured","confidence":1.0,"missing_reason":null},"visibility_v3":{"state":"measured","confidence":1.0,"missing_reason":null},"performance_v4":{"state":"measured","confidence":0.6,"missing_reason":null},"corroboration_v1":{"state":"not_collected","confidence":0.0,"missing_reason":"corroboration_sources_missing"}}},"traffic":{"latest_snapshot":{"snapshot_date":"2026-07-19","organic_clicks":1,"organic_impressions":539,"average_position":"39.9","indexed_pages":null},"weekly_snapshots":[{"label":"Jun 15","clicks":0,"impressions":0},{"label":"Jun 22","clicks":0,"impressions":0},{"label":"Jun 29","clicks":0,"impressions":0},{"label":"Jul 6","clicks":0,"impressions":0},{"label":"Jul 13","clicks":1,"impressions":1037}]},"trust_growth_score":{"value":27,"tier":null,"rank_eligible":false,"score_date":"2026-09-13"},"core_web_vitals":{"lcp_ms":7351,"cls_score":"0.0","inp_ms":170,"lcp_status":"poor","cls_status":"good","inp_status":"good"},"social":{"operator_same_as":[],"brand_same_as":[]},"visibility":{"captured_on":"2026-09-13","metrics":{"visibility_index":{"value":100.0,"raw_value":100.0},"share_of_voice_pct":100.0,"estimated_traffic":27,"estimated_traffic_value_usd":12.57,"keywords_ranked":70,"top3_count":0,"top10_count":0},"verified_rankings":[]},"issues":[{"label":"Broken Links","severity":"warning","recorded_severity":"critical","classification":"issue","policy_version":"audit-remediation-v3","issue_type":"broken_link","page_url":"https://atlasofthinkers.com/blog/why-zhuangzi-wasnt-sure-he-was-a-man","description":"Internal link to https://atlasofthinkers.com/ideas/dao returned 404","remediation":{"why_it_matters":"A confirmed dead destination can interrupt a useful journey. A timeout or transient server failure does not establish a permanently broken link.","steps":["Confirm the applicability and required context before preparing any change.","Applies after a GET-capable probe confirms an unintended dead destination. Prioritize internal/key-journey links and repeated failures; transient 5xx remains investigation. Correct the href, restore the target, or remove the link.","Verify the result against the conditions below."],"preserve":["Preserve complete authored meaning, accurate claims, accessibility, security, and intentional crawler/canonical policy."],"avoid":["Redirect every dead URL home, replace with an unrelated destination, remove useful anchor context, or treat a timeout as a 404."],"no_change_when":["Keep the current implementation when the applicability conditions are not met or the existing implementation already serves its intended purpose."],"verification":["Link reaches the intended relevant resource with expected status/content; key journey and anchor meaning still work."],"sources":[{"title":"HTTP semantics","url":"https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc9110.html"},{"title":"Google crawl errors","url":"https://developers.google.com/search/docs/crawling-indexing/troubleshoot-crawling-errors"}],"reviewed_on":"2026-09-05","required_context":["get_probe_confirmed","intended_destination","condition_confirmed"],"scoring_policy":{"version":"audit-remediation-v1","eligible":true,"interpretation":"proposed_policy","explanation":"Proposed penalty eligibility is separate from the published formula and does not prove that this finding contributed to a score.","published":{"formula_uid":"71r1infxz5uz","formula_version":1,"formula_name":"standing-first-v1","technical_signal":"technical_v5","score_date":"2026-09-13","scoring_policy_version":null,"status":"unavailable","eligible":null}},"guidance_available":true,"applicability":"unknown","applicability_conditions":"Applies after a GET-capable probe confirms an unintended dead destination. Prioritize internal/key-journey links and repeated failures; transient 5xx remains investigation. Correct the href, restore the target, or remove the link.","ownership":"crawler","material_policy_version":"broken_link:2","automation":"investigate","observation":"Broken Links","recommended_action":"Investigate the current evidence and required context before proposing a change. Applies after a GET-capable probe confirms an unintended dead destination. Prioritize internal/key-journey links and repeated failures; transient 5xx remains investigation. Correct the href, restore the target, or remove the link.","proposed_change":null,"context":{},"evidence":{"id":1104373,"state":"complete","captured_at":"2026-09-13T11:00:34.350637","http_status":200,"check_manifest":{"meta_tags":{"title":"Why Zhuangzi Wasn't Sure He Was a Man · Atlas of Thinkers","verdict":"pass","candidates":[],"checker_version":"page-checks-v1","meta_description":"Zhuangzi dreamed he was a butterfly, then woke unable to say which one of them was real. A look at the philosopher who turned uncertainty into freedom."},"eeat_evidence":{"h2":["the limits of a viewpoint","the turtle in the mud","the dream that won't end"],"version":"eeat-evidence-v1","h2_count":3,"has_ol_li":false,"has_table":false,"word_count":3813,"author_names":[],"has_pre_code":false,"h2_step_match":false,"h3_step_match":false,"has_canvas_svg":true,"blockquote_long":false,"testimonial_css":false,"trusted_by_text":false,"for_example_text":false,"logo_partner_css":false,"news_domain_link":false,"star_rating_text":false,"our_data_shows_text":false,"internal_links_count":32,"screenshot_alt_count":0,"technical_terms_text":true},"geo_readiness":{"verdict":"fail","candidates":[{"page_url":"https://atlasofthinkers.com/blog/why-zhuangzi-wasnt-sure-he-was-a-man","severity":"info","check_key":"geo_readiness","issue_type":"missing_faq_section","scope_kind":"page","description":"No FAQ section detected in page content","fingerprint":"235e2c201c8b6e16310ad0e2136024a1bce7c8183b49e22f42d7e191e1c2654b","site_page_id":23146,"discriminator":""},{"page_url":"https://atlasofthinkers.com/blog/why-zhuangzi-wasnt-sure-he-was-a-man","severity":"info","check_key":"geo_readiness","issue_type":"low_outbound_authority_links","scope_kind":"page","description":"Only 0 external link(s) found; consider citing authoritative sources","fingerprint":"2e877a4a6e4aadd30125d3d16ae07b7df0dad7f36c06c5698c9acfa7001d9bb2","site_page_id":23146,"discriminator":""}],"eligibility":{"low_list_usage":1,"faq_not_marked_up":0,"incomplete_schema":1,"missing_faq_section":1,"missing_update_date":1,"missing_publish_date":1,"missing_schema_types":1,"missing_author_markup":1,"poor_heading_hierarchy":1,"low_outbound_authority_links":1},"checker_version":"page-checks-v1"},"schema_markup":{"verdict":"pass","candidates":[],"checker_version":"page-checks-v1"},"review_evidence":{"no_h1":"review-facts-v1:cd6247264f778a8e04862bedc0d2a8433dc497cdb298b82cc87dd6907ea3459b","no_schema":"review-facts-v1:7ed281a0cbd307bbe00d3be0850ce29a11b33de6bc73cbaea510205ae29c499f","multiple_h1":"review-facts-v1:cd6247264f778a8e04862bedc0d2a8433dc497cdb298b82cc87dd6907ea3459b","meta_missing":"review-facts-v1:d5d4f58e7d4eed09a78abdd867b25bc79c505f347bd37be4298466186200fbf3","no_canonical":"review-facts-v1:b6c839a7a1ea6c526db1b958580db79adf6fe74db014a44fdbc15f41a479206a","meta_too_long":"review-facts-v1:d5d4f58e7d4eed09a78abdd867b25bc79c505f347bd37be4298466186200fbf3","invalid_schema":"review-facts-v1:7ed281a0cbd307bbe00d3be0850ce29a11b33de6bc73cbaea510205ae29c499f","low_list_usage":"review-facts-v1:c829b0d28b65a61c2894e5e076fc3ccfef1c399f3415939e8603b07b44c4f763","meta_too_short":"review-facts-v1:d5d4f58e7d4eed09a78abdd867b25bc79c505f347bd37be4298466186200fbf3","faq_not_marked_up":"review-facts-v1:3c387cabc27bb5702c74345f9868b625a85bf08949a127382e174c30d8ba3ad6","incomplete_schema":"review-facts-v1:8a184068a583a65453beb1e496b0419fd1a3dd9dec09a8a23cf234e59c7ecc0a","meta_title_missing":"review-facts-v1:b422de9f6ad7f0d1409878a7a7ac8aa905fe731c671d19dc077afd25a2ae3ecf","meta_title_too_long":"review-facts-v1:b422de9f6ad7f0d1409878a7a7ac8aa905fe731c671d19dc077afd25a2ae3ecf","missing_faq_section":"review-facts-v1:3c387cabc27bb5702c74345f9868b625a85bf08949a127382e174c30d8ba3ad6","missing_update_date":"review-facts-v1:2d86c5a5aa365e214a73dffc1ce557d70d9a3b6ca54d55e87ee71495777f1733","meta_title_too_short":"review-facts-v1:b422de9f6ad7f0d1409878a7a7ac8aa905fe731c671d19dc077afd25a2ae3ecf","missing_publish_date":"review-facts-v1:60ca80075131e14c69191b725b8b9d66360b9d573e964efa1f55b20f42f0680f","missing_schema_types":"review-facts-v1:bb03d4ffb773f59b5f6a335429bdc2ed75fa25a09b6796a61fb1aa1334abc02e","missing_author_markup":"review-facts-v1:e774ecddff3a34d84b6b30287be1b220e1a91580a1dd144b42ee91a3243b9ba2","poor_heading_hierarchy":"review-facts-v1:ac15b7762ea300989f48e163a4e648b7ed063be66afb9746cd2b57708a710972","meta_description_missing":"review-facts-v1:995d30dd1113e76b5bef3c3587c8b89dc5c5c60196e8f05f2743b326082ea137","meta_description_too_long":"review-facts-v1:995d30dd1113e76b5bef3c3587c8b89dc5c5c60196e8f05f2743b326082ea137","meta_description_too_short":"review-facts-v1:995d30dd1113e76b5bef3c3587c8b89dc5c5c60196e8f05f2743b326082ea137","low_outbound_authority_links":"review-facts-v1:97294f05c3603881a6466e787eb8726dde04588d242bea02914b0f0a8e12bdb2"}},"latest_attempt":{"id":1104373,"state":"complete","started_at":"2026-09-13T11:00:34.116637","captured_at":"2026-09-13T11:00:34.350637","http_status":200},"priority_measurement":null}}},{"label":"Slow LCP","severity":"info","recorded_severity":"critical","classification":"issue","policy_version":"audit-remediation-v3","issue_type":"slow_lcp","page_url":"https://atlasofthinkers.com","description":"LCP is 7351ms (threshold: 4000ms; source: lab)","remediation":{"why_it_matters":"Slow loading of the largest visible content can affect user experience. A single synthetic measurement may not represent actual visitors.","steps":["Confirm the applicability and required context before preparing any change.","Investigate the measurement source and scope first. Diagnose the actual LCP element and TTFB, load, and render delay.","Verify the result against the conditions below."],"preserve":["Preserve complete authored meaning, accurate claims, accessibility, security, and intentional crawler/canonical policy."],"avoid":["Hide/remove meaningful hero content, optimize only the audit device, or declare a one-run delta fixed."],"no_change_when":["Keep the current implementation when the applicability conditions are not met or the existing implementation already serves its intended purpose."],"verification":["Field p75 improves across representative mobile/desktop traffic; repeated lab traces corroborate cause."],"sources":[{"title":"web.dev LCP","url":"https://web.dev/articles/lcp"},{"title":"Lighthouse variability","url":"https://github.com/GoogleChrome/lighthouse/blob/main/docs/variability.md"}],"reviewed_on":"2026-09-05","required_context":["representative_field_data","condition_confirmed"],"scoring_policy":{"version":"audit-remediation-v1","eligible":true,"interpretation":"proposed_policy","explanation":"Proposed penalty eligibility is separate from the published formula and does not prove that this finding contributed to a score.","published":{"formula_uid":"71r1infxz5uz","formula_version":1,"formula_name":"standing-first-v1","technical_signal":"technical_v5","score_date":"2026-09-13","scoring_policy_version":null,"status":"unavailable","eligible":null}},"guidance_available":true,"applicability":"unknown","applicability_conditions":"Warning only when the current homepage metric is poor and matches the selected mobile PageSpeed run with field_page or field_origin provenance. Lab-only, uncorrelated, and missing-source measurements remain informational investigations. Field-origin data describes origin traffic, not proof for each individual page.","ownership":"performance","material_policy_version":"slow_lcp:2","automation":"investigate","observation":"Slow LCP","recommended_action":"Investigate the current evidence and required context before proposing a change. Investigate the measurement source and scope first. Diagnose the actual LCP element and TTFB, load, and render delay.","proposed_change":null,"context":{},"evidence":{"latest_attempt":null,"priority_measurement":{"lcp_ms":7351,"audit_id":1028,"strategy":"mobile","cls_score":0,"cls_source":"lab","lcp_source":"lab"}}}},{"label":"Incomplete Schema","severity":"info","recorded_severity":"warning","classification":"suggestion","policy_version":"audit-remediation-v3","issue_type":"incomplete_schema","page_url":"https://atlasofthinkers.com/","description":"Schema exists but missing: author, dateModified","remediation":{"why_it_matters":"Required properties depend on the exact type and consumer. Invented values are worse than fewer accurate properties.","steps":["Confirm the applicability and required context before preparing any change.","Applies only to missing properties documented for that exact type and use. Add genuine required/recommended data when available; fewer accurate properties are preferable.","Verify the result against the conditions below."],"preserve":["Preserve complete authored meaning, accurate claims, accessibility, security, and intentional crawler/canonical policy."],"avoid":["Apply `author/datePublished/dateModified` to every WebPage/CollectionPage or invent values."],"no_change_when":["Keep fewer accurate properties when the supposed missing property does not apply or the real value is unavailable."],"verification":["Type-specific validator passes and every property matches visible, maintained facts."],"sources":[{"title":"Google structured-data introduction","url":"https://developers.google.com/search/docs/appearance/structured-data/intro-structured-data"},{"title":"policies","url":"https://developers.google.com/search/docs/appearance/structured-data/sd-policies"}],"reviewed_on":"2026-09-05","required_context":["target_consumer","feature_eligible","all_schema_formats_checked","condition_confirmed"],"scoring_policy":{"version":"audit-remediation-v1","eligible":true,"interpretation":"proposed_policy","explanation":"Proposed penalty eligibility is separate from the published formula and does not prove that this finding contributed to a score.","published":{"formula_uid":"71r1infxz5uz","formula_version":1,"formula_name":"standing-first-v1","technical_signal":"technical_v5","score_date":"2026-09-13","scoring_policy_version":null,"status":"unavailable","eligible":null}},"guidance_available":true,"applicability":"unknown","applicability_conditions":"Applies only to missing properties documented for that exact type and use. Add genuine required/recommended data when available; fewer accurate properties are preferable.","ownership":"crawler","material_policy_version":"incomplete_schema:2","automation":"advisory_only","observation":"Incomplete Schema","recommended_action":"Applies only to missing properties documented for that exact type and use. Add genuine required/recommended data when available; fewer accurate properties are preferable.","proposed_change":null,"context":{},"evidence":{"id":1104193,"state":"complete","captured_at":"2026-09-13T11:00:05.600539","http_status":200,"check_manifest":{"meta_tags":{"title":"Atlas of Thinkers, A World History of Philosophy","verdict":"pass","candidates":[],"checker_version":"page-checks-v1","meta_description":"An interactive philosophy atlas: ten volumes from ancient Greece to the present, with journeys, maps, timelines, and daily reading across the world of thought."},"eeat_evidence":{"h2":["what is stoicism?","what is existentialism?","what is islamic philosophy?","what was ancient greek philosophy?","ten volumes","ancient greece","read, map, compare, or simply wander.","letters from the atlas"],"version":"eeat-evidence-v1","h2_count":8,"has_ol_li":false,"has_table":false,"word_count":4416,"author_names":[],"has_pre_code":false,"h2_step_match":false,"h3_step_match":false,"has_canvas_svg":true,"blockquote_long":true,"testimonial_css":false,"trusted_by_text":false,"for_example_text":false,"logo_partner_css":false,"news_domain_link":false,"star_rating_text":false,"our_data_shows_text":false,"internal_links_count":66,"screenshot_alt_count":1,"technical_terms_text":true},"geo_readiness":{"verdict":"fail","candidates":[{"page_url":"https://atlasofthinkers.com/","severity":"warning","check_key":"geo_readiness","issue_type":"incomplete_schema","scope_kind":"page","description":"Schema exists but missing: author, dateModified","fingerprint":"62bac39ba1c1cf56d1728c49ba9ea3743039f14d3439d49cac157f669ae744cc","site_page_id":23032,"discriminator":""},{"page_url":"https://atlasofthinkers.com/","severity":"info","check_key":"geo_readiness","issue_type":"missing_update_date","scope_kind":"page","description":"No update date found in schema or meta tags","fingerprint":"8f113616658daf4fda7c233e5bb46c8688a645bec7591f7641f44cce64c8f576","site_page_id":23032,"discriminator":""}],"eligibility":{"low_list_usage":1,"faq_not_marked_up":0,"incomplete_schema":1,"missing_faq_section":0,"missing_update_date":1,"missing_publish_date":0,"missing_schema_types":1,"missing_author_markup":0,"poor_heading_hierarchy":1,"low_outbound_authority_links":1},"checker_version":"page-checks-v1"},"schema_markup":{"verdict":"pass","candidates":[],"checker_version":"page-checks-v1"},"review_evidence":{"no_h1":"review-facts-v1:5c0e916e2348e04ddce227a96222c1bed43972766fe2209648f2d2425a135a5d","no_schema":"review-facts-v1:952e75685e6d3e61ef2520bf97752d1e4675c3722a42386d7a098afcbf028c3a","multiple_h1":"review-facts-v1:5c0e916e2348e04ddce227a96222c1bed43972766fe2209648f2d2425a135a5d","meta_missing":"review-facts-v1:449c1db2988972340d5f1483f4facb569540b6f55f42249136dac085a53ab76a","no_canonical":"review-facts-v1:f1d6c3fa161487461384835246131c16cc140aef1c50bfd43b8ac727a7bb8e29","meta_too_long":"review-facts-v1:449c1db2988972340d5f1483f4facb569540b6f55f42249136dac085a53ab76a","invalid_schema":"review-facts-v1:952e75685e6d3e61ef2520bf97752d1e4675c3722a42386d7a098afcbf028c3a","low_list_usage":"review-facts-v1:39595e583c06ee3c19fc172a39fc8f9662919d810ad90ed5d78021eb7ca54c8f","meta_too_short":"review-facts-v1:449c1db2988972340d5f1483f4facb569540b6f55f42249136dac085a53ab76a","faq_not_marked_up":"review-facts-v1:27b38f5388800de0c6b619866c3b1a897f2f205897b0b47507164c981dfe489f","incomplete_schema":"review-facts-v1:7a09f7ce773271331e04debc105970eba20acc312edc3e389e64ef9395557ad3","meta_title_missing":"review-facts-v1:f1a7ab694d0ee576ef12f78af31257ba7343aeba2f81d3bb27893cdcc8f4fb43","meta_title_too_long":"review-facts-v1:f1a7ab694d0ee576ef12f78af31257ba7343aeba2f81d3bb27893cdcc8f4fb43","missing_faq_section":"review-facts-v1:27b38f5388800de0c6b619866c3b1a897f2f205897b0b47507164c981dfe489f","missing_update_date":"review-facts-v1:7bf9c64c5193f28651c2086d596307cdeba4466ddf572b70c9ad1682fe2617db","meta_title_too_short":"review-facts-v1:f1a7ab694d0ee576ef12f78af31257ba7343aeba2f81d3bb27893cdcc8f4fb43","missing_publish_date":"review-facts-v1:7bf9c64c5193f28651c2086d596307cdeba4466ddf572b70c9ad1682fe2617db","missing_schema_types":"review-facts-v1:7a09f7ce773271331e04debc105970eba20acc312edc3e389e64ef9395557ad3","missing_author_markup":"review-facts-v1:7bf9c64c5193f28651c2086d596307cdeba4466ddf572b70c9ad1682fe2617db","poor_heading_hierarchy":"review-facts-v1:961264aad132a95efd04a0ea00da6aabb6bc2de7fdd2b8d6715689cd96235e21","meta_description_missing":"review-facts-v1:f66bd28bf9fc670082b8256f3773ddc7a51f9c62e566c935910bbdce1aec9b7b","meta_description_too_long":"review-facts-v1:f66bd28bf9fc670082b8256f3773ddc7a51f9c62e566c935910bbdce1aec9b7b","meta_description_too_short":"review-facts-v1:f66bd28bf9fc670082b8256f3773ddc7a51f9c62e566c935910bbdce1aec9b7b","low_outbound_authority_links":"review-facts-v1:7f22d943d98ff55634db85a78e0e57bdbe8a44104c83f5d55d020e2c99d3c4b0"}},"latest_attempt":{"id":1104193,"state":"complete","started_at":"2026-09-13T11:00:05.461539","captured_at":"2026-09-13T11:00:05.600539","http_status":200},"priority_measurement":null}}},{"label":"Missing Update Date","severity":"info","recorded_severity":"info","classification":"suggestion","policy_version":"audit-remediation-v3","issue_type":"missing_update_date","page_url":"https://atlasofthinkers.com/","description":"No update date found in schema or meta tags","remediation":{"why_it_matters":"A true modified date can explain a substantive revision. Rebuilding a page is not evidence of editorial freshness.","steps":["Confirm the applicability and required context before preparing any change.","Applies only after a substantive revision whose date matters. Add a truthful modified date; N/A for unchanged or timeless pages.","Verify the result against the conditions below."],"preserve":["Preserve complete authored meaning, accurate claims, accessibility, security, and intentional crawler/canonical policy."],"avoid":["Refresh dates automatically to appear fresh or equate a rebuild with editorial revision."],"no_change_when":["Keep unchanged or timeless pages without a modified date; a build or deployment is not an editorial revision."],"verification":["Revision evidence supports the date; visible and structured values agree."],"sources":[{"title":"Google Article markup","url":"https://developers.google.com/search/docs/appearance/structured-data/article"},{"title":"people-first guidance","url":"https://developers.google.com/search/docs/fundamentals/creating-helpful-content"}],"reviewed_on":"2026-09-05","required_context":["substantive_revision","true_revision_date","condition_confirmed"],"scoring_policy":{"version":"audit-remediation-v1","eligible":true,"interpretation":"proposed_policy","explanation":"Proposed penalty eligibility is separate from the published formula and does not prove that this finding contributed to a score.","published":{"formula_uid":"71r1infxz5uz","formula_version":1,"formula_name":"standing-first-v1","technical_signal":"technical_v5","score_date":"2026-09-13","scoring_policy_version":null,"status":"unavailable","eligible":null}},"guidance_available":true,"applicability":"unknown","applicability_conditions":"Applies only after a substantive revision whose date matters. Add a truthful modified date; N/A for unchanged or timeless pages.","ownership":"crawler","material_policy_version":"missing_update_date:2","automation":"advisory_only","observation":"Missing Update Date","recommended_action":"Applies only after a substantive revision whose date matters. Add a truthful modified date; N/A for unchanged or timeless pages.","proposed_change":null,"context":{},"evidence":{"id":1104193,"state":"complete","captured_at":"2026-09-13T11:00:05.600539","http_status":200,"check_manifest":{"meta_tags":{"title":"Atlas of Thinkers, A World History of Philosophy","verdict":"pass","candidates":[],"checker_version":"page-checks-v1","meta_description":"An interactive philosophy atlas: ten volumes from ancient Greece to the present, with journeys, maps, timelines, and daily reading across the world of thought."},"eeat_evidence":{"h2":["what is stoicism?","what is existentialism?","what is islamic philosophy?","what was ancient greek philosophy?","ten volumes","ancient greece","read, map, compare, or simply wander.","letters from the atlas"],"version":"eeat-evidence-v1","h2_count":8,"has_ol_li":false,"has_table":false,"word_count":4416,"author_names":[],"has_pre_code":false,"h2_step_match":false,"h3_step_match":false,"has_canvas_svg":true,"blockquote_long":true,"testimonial_css":false,"trusted_by_text":false,"for_example_text":false,"logo_partner_css":false,"news_domain_link":false,"star_rating_text":false,"our_data_shows_text":false,"internal_links_count":66,"screenshot_alt_count":1,"technical_terms_text":true},"geo_readiness":{"verdict":"fail","candidates":[{"page_url":"https://atlasofthinkers.com/","severity":"warning","check_key":"geo_readiness","issue_type":"incomplete_schema","scope_kind":"page","description":"Schema exists but missing: author, dateModified","fingerprint":"62bac39ba1c1cf56d1728c49ba9ea3743039f14d3439d49cac157f669ae744cc","site_page_id":23032,"discriminator":""},{"page_url":"https://atlasofthinkers.com/","severity":"info","check_key":"geo_readiness","issue_type":"missing_update_date","scope_kind":"page","description":"No update date found in schema or meta tags","fingerprint":"8f113616658daf4fda7c233e5bb46c8688a645bec7591f7641f44cce64c8f576","site_page_id":23032,"discriminator":""}],"eligibility":{"low_list_usage":1,"faq_not_marked_up":0,"incomplete_schema":1,"missing_faq_section":0,"missing_update_date":1,"missing_publish_date":0,"missing_schema_types":1,"missing_author_markup":0,"poor_heading_hierarchy":1,"low_outbound_authority_links":1},"checker_version":"page-checks-v1"},"schema_markup":{"verdict":"pass","candidates":[],"checker_version":"page-checks-v1"},"review_evidence":{"no_h1":"review-facts-v1:5c0e916e2348e04ddce227a96222c1bed43972766fe2209648f2d2425a135a5d","no_schema":"review-facts-v1:952e75685e6d3e61ef2520bf97752d1e4675c3722a42386d7a098afcbf028c3a","multiple_h1":"review-facts-v1:5c0e916e2348e04ddce227a96222c1bed43972766fe2209648f2d2425a135a5d","meta_missing":"review-facts-v1:449c1db2988972340d5f1483f4facb569540b6f55f42249136dac085a53ab76a","no_canonical":"review-facts-v1:f1d6c3fa161487461384835246131c16cc140aef1c50bfd43b8ac727a7bb8e29","meta_too_long":"review-facts-v1:449c1db2988972340d5f1483f4facb569540b6f55f42249136dac085a53ab76a","invalid_schema":"review-facts-v1:952e75685e6d3e61ef2520bf97752d1e4675c3722a42386d7a098afcbf028c3a","low_list_usage":"review-facts-v1:39595e583c06ee3c19fc172a39fc8f9662919d810ad90ed5d78021eb7ca54c8f","meta_too_short":"review-facts-v1:449c1db2988972340d5f1483f4facb569540b6f55f42249136dac085a53ab76a","faq_not_marked_up":"review-facts-v1:27b38f5388800de0c6b619866c3b1a897f2f205897b0b47507164c981dfe489f","incomplete_schema":"review-facts-v1:7a09f7ce773271331e04debc105970eba20acc312edc3e389e64ef9395557ad3","meta_title_missing":"review-facts-v1:f1a7ab694d0ee576ef12f78af31257ba7343aeba2f81d3bb27893cdcc8f4fb43","meta_title_too_long":"review-facts-v1:f1a7ab694d0ee576ef12f78af31257ba7343aeba2f81d3bb27893cdcc8f4fb43","missing_faq_section":"review-facts-v1:27b38f5388800de0c6b619866c3b1a897f2f205897b0b47507164c981dfe489f","missing_update_date":"review-facts-v1:7bf9c64c5193f28651c2086d596307cdeba4466ddf572b70c9ad1682fe2617db","meta_title_too_short":"review-facts-v1:f1a7ab694d0ee576ef12f78af31257ba7343aeba2f81d3bb27893cdcc8f4fb43","missing_publish_date":"review-facts-v1:7bf9c64c5193f28651c2086d596307cdeba4466ddf572b70c9ad1682fe2617db","missing_schema_types":"review-facts-v1:7a09f7ce773271331e04debc105970eba20acc312edc3e389e64ef9395557ad3","missing_author_markup":"review-facts-v1:7bf9c64c5193f28651c2086d596307cdeba4466ddf572b70c9ad1682fe2617db","poor_heading_hierarchy":"review-facts-v1:961264aad132a95efd04a0ea00da6aabb6bc2de7fdd2b8d6715689cd96235e21","meta_description_missing":"review-facts-v1:f66bd28bf9fc670082b8256f3773ddc7a51f9c62e566c935910bbdce1aec9b7b","meta_description_too_long":"review-facts-v1:f66bd28bf9fc670082b8256f3773ddc7a51f9c62e566c935910bbdce1aec9b7b","meta_description_too_short":"review-facts-v1:f66bd28bf9fc670082b8256f3773ddc7a51f9c62e566c935910bbdce1aec9b7b","low_outbound_authority_links":"review-facts-v1:7f22d943d98ff55634db85a78e0e57bdbe8a44104c83f5d55d020e2c99d3c4b0"}},"latest_attempt":{"id":1104193,"state":"complete","started_at":"2026-09-13T11:00:05.461539","captured_at":"2026-09-13T11:00:05.600539","http_status":200},"priority_measurement":null}}},{"label":"Missing Schema Types","severity":"info","recorded_severity":"warning","classification":"suggestion","policy_version":"audit-remediation-v3","issue_type":"missing_schema_types","page_url":"https://atlasofthinkers.com/about","description":"No GEO-relevant page-level schema type found. Accepted types/families: Article, BlogPosting, Product, Organization, FAQPage, HowTo, CollectionPage, WebPage, CreativeWork; accepted subtypes: ContactPage, Blog, SoftwareApplication. Only top-level @type and @graph item @type describe the page; nested properties such as publisher do not count as the page's own type.","remediation":{"why_it_matters":"The detector uses a product allowlist. A missing allowlisted type is not a universal indexing or AI-visibility requirement.","steps":["Confirm the applicability and required context before preparing any change.","Provisional TrustGrowth allowlist, not a general web/AI requirement. Advisory only after mapping page type to a supported consumer feature; otherwise N/A.","Verify the result against the conditions below."],"preserve":["Preserve complete authored meaning, accurate claims, accessibility, security, and intentional crawler/canonical policy."],"avoid":["Add one of the allowlisted types merely to clear the audit or describe a different entity as the page."],"no_change_when":["Keep the current markup when it represents the page accurately and no identified consumer requires another type."],"verification":["Chosen type accurately represents the page and has an identified consumer/use; no-change is allowed."],"sources":[{"title":"Google structured-data introduction","url":"https://developers.google.com/search/docs/appearance/structured-data/intro-structured-data"},{"title":"Google AI guidance","url":"https://developers.google.com/search/docs/fundamentals/ai-optimization-guide"}],"reviewed_on":"2026-09-05","required_context":["target_consumer","feature_eligible","all_schema_formats_checked","condition_confirmed"],"scoring_policy":{"version":"audit-remediation-v1","eligible":true,"interpretation":"proposed_policy","explanation":"Proposed penalty eligibility is separate from the published formula and does not prove that this finding contributed to a score.","published":{"formula_uid":"71r1infxz5uz","formula_version":1,"formula_name":"standing-first-v1","technical_signal":"technical_v5","score_date":"2026-09-13","scoring_policy_version":null,"status":"unavailable","eligible":null}},"guidance_available":true,"applicability":"unknown","applicability_conditions":"Provisional TrustGrowth allowlist, not a general web/AI requirement. Advisory only after mapping page type to a supported consumer feature; otherwise N/A.","ownership":"crawler","material_policy_version":"missing_schema_types:2","automation":"advisory_only","observation":"Missing Schema Types","recommended_action":"Provisional TrustGrowth allowlist, not a general web/AI requirement. Advisory only after mapping page type to a supported consumer feature; otherwise N/A.","proposed_change":null,"context":{},"evidence":{"id":1104197,"state":"complete","captured_at":"2026-09-13T11:00:06.025332","http_status":200,"check_manifest":{"meta_tags":{"title":"About Atlas of Thinkers · Atlas of Thinkers","verdict":"pass","candidates":[],"checker_version":"page-checks-v1","meta_description":"Atlas of Thinkers is a story-first philosophy atlas: an interactive, map-driven storybook where you can explore philosophers through place, time, movement, idea"},"eeat_evidence":{"h2":["the ten volumes","how to explore","confidence & uncertainty","credits"],"version":"eeat-evidence-v1","h2_count":4,"has_ol_li":false,"has_table":false,"word_count":2813,"author_names":[],"has_pre_code":false,"h2_step_match":false,"h3_step_match":false,"has_canvas_svg":true,"blockquote_long":false,"testimonial_css":false,"trusted_by_text":false,"for_example_text":false,"logo_partner_css":false,"news_domain_link":false,"star_rating_text":false,"our_data_shows_text":false,"internal_links_count":30,"screenshot_alt_count":0,"technical_terms_text":true},"geo_readiness":{"verdict":"fail","candidates":[{"page_url":"https://atlasofthinkers.com/about","severity":"warning","check_key":"geo_readiness","issue_type":"missing_schema_types","scope_kind":"page","description":"No GEO-relevant page-level schema type found. Accepted types/families: Article, BlogPosting, Product, Organization, FAQPage, HowTo, CollectionPage, WebPage, CreativeWork; accepted subtypes: ContactPage, Blog, SoftwareApplication. Only top-level @type and @graph item @type describe the page; nested properties such as publisher do not count as the page's own type.","fingerprint":"48befb546ec7b378c3aa0b979b96b91c530504a4b47dff48124dee734fa7a6a5","site_page_id":23099,"discriminator":""},{"page_url":"https://atlasofthinkers.com/about","severity":"info","check_key":"geo_readiness","issue_type":"low_outbound_authority_links","scope_kind":"page","description":"Only 0 external link(s) found; consider citing authoritative sources","fingerprint":"a9c804e0813fb8b645d9b0356fc9f73704bb2672e22051b0114f7e7223d54436","site_page_id":23099,"discriminator":""}],"eligibility":{"low_list_usage":1,"faq_not_marked_up":0,"incomplete_schema":0,"missing_faq_section":0,"missing_update_date":0,"missing_publish_date":0,"missing_schema_types":1,"missing_author_markup":0,"poor_heading_hierarchy":1,"low_outbound_authority_links":1},"checker_version":"page-checks-v1"},"schema_markup":{"verdict":"fail","candidates":[{"page_url":"https://atlasofthinkers.com/about","severity":"warning","check_key":"schema_markup","issue_type":"no_schema","scope_kind":"page","description":"No structured data (JSON-LD) found","fingerprint":"c2ddf198750beb73d1d313e391c5e79adf7fedbfed730208ed048557a2c11145","site_page_id":23099,"discriminator":""}],"checker_version":"page-checks-v1"},"review_evidence":{"no_h1":"review-facts-v1:06f144e14377eddeaae9c6fecc5fa2d4d095814ef90b5e40e91b21bce975d969","no_schema":"review-facts-v1:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945","multiple_h1":"review-facts-v1:06f144e14377eddeaae9c6fecc5fa2d4d095814ef90b5e40e91b21bce975d969","meta_missing":"review-facts-v1:e722aa8880e6ad612a86c63008af66aba44f369d6793be0573547f5d3144fac8","no_canonical":"review-facts-v1:a5241de385d1dca85519952ec0f59b60e9369d8b2e6ffb28a0f067fa71105759","meta_too_long":"review-facts-v1:e722aa8880e6ad612a86c63008af66aba44f369d6793be0573547f5d3144fac8","invalid_schema":"review-facts-v1:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945","low_list_usage":"review-facts-v1:cd8637df2b4ea1cc34b198adabaaa327b0cd711f689bc63e5f503291a3a7127b","meta_too_short":"review-facts-v1:e722aa8880e6ad612a86c63008af66aba44f369d6793be0573547f5d3144fac8","faq_not_marked_up":"review-facts-v1:7d4c437a0159bc4d476fd35ed17aa5a3745b59104b6f37f5abcfc45553fc3897","incomplete_schema":"review-facts-v1:97294f05c3603881a6466e787eb8726dde04588d242bea02914b0f0a8e12bdb2","meta_title_missing":"review-facts-v1:5be407b065295f400faeadd4b1c86bcc8e76f5775f074efedc9a97f5e3767b99","meta_title_too_long":"review-facts-v1:5be407b065295f400faeadd4b1c86bcc8e76f5775f074efedc9a97f5e3767b99","missing_faq_section":"review-facts-v1:7d4c437a0159bc4d476fd35ed17aa5a3745b59104b6f37f5abcfc45553fc3897","missing_update_date":"review-facts-v1:797e3dc8a48bf4fe78ba892d5e966be12cef8bef05dc91043d6421768de0b5c0","meta_title_too_short":"review-facts-v1:5be407b065295f400faeadd4b1c86bcc8e76f5775f074efedc9a97f5e3767b99","missing_publish_date":"review-facts-v1:797e3dc8a48bf4fe78ba892d5e966be12cef8bef05dc91043d6421768de0b5c0","missing_schema_types":"review-facts-v1:97294f05c3603881a6466e787eb8726dde04588d242bea02914b0f0a8e12bdb2","missing_author_markup":"review-facts-v1:797e3dc8a48bf4fe78ba892d5e966be12cef8bef05dc91043d6421768de0b5c0","poor_heading_hierarchy":"review-facts-v1:2e3452fdb55a7b4900f6138e245ccbf084e78d30412e1d772272beb6368b3b8e","meta_description_missing":"review-facts-v1:ca95252cd567d16d0421131ea98dcdedc3f4a508ac9092a5f64ab6fe2f7a0c08","meta_description_too_long":"review-facts-v1:ca95252cd567d16d0421131ea98dcdedc3f4a508ac9092a5f64ab6fe2f7a0c08","meta_description_too_short":"review-facts-v1:ca95252cd567d16d0421131ea98dcdedc3f4a508ac9092a5f64ab6fe2f7a0c08","low_outbound_authority_links":"review-facts-v1:97294f05c3603881a6466e787eb8726dde04588d242bea02914b0f0a8e12bdb2"}},"latest_attempt":{"id":1104197,"state":"complete","started_at":"2026-09-13T11:00:05.804332","captured_at":"2026-09-13T11:00:06.025332","http_status":200},"priority_measurement":null}}}]}